Questions about WSI

What the numbers mean, how to read them and where the judgment comes in.

What is a Universal Suffering Unit?

A USU expresses an amount of experienced suffering using an assumed intensity and duration. For the current WSI estimates, one USU is a stipulated six-hour kidney-stone pain reference totaling 47.25 intensity-hours. It gives us a common unit; it does not establish that different experiences are equivalent.

Read the reference definition →

Why is reducing suffering important?

Relief matters for the person experiencing pain or distress. Its value does not depend on a person’s productivity, income or potential achievements.

Suffering can also make it harder to direct attention toward other parts of life. Easing it can give people more room to learn, create, connect with others and pursue their goals. The resulting possibilities for communities and human progress are part of WSI’s motivation, not a guaranteed outcome of every intervention.

Research offers evidence for some of these barriers. A study of 40 people with chronic pain linked attentional interference to the interaction of pain severity and pain-related fear. A laboratory experiment with 42 participants found poorer decision quality under acute stress, with effects varying by stress response and task complexity. These studies examine specific tasks; they do not directly measure creativity or humanity’s progress.

Our USU estimates count the specified experienced suffering or relief. They do not automatically include wider effects on learning, work or innovation. Read about WSI’s purpose →

Why introduce a new unit?

Case counts describe how many cases are reported; death counts describe lives lost. Neither on its own describes how intensely people suffer or for how long. USU combines the number of people or episodes with an assumed intensity and duration, so different experiences can be expressed on a common scale.

A reference pain episode makes that scale more concrete than an unexplained score. Our kidney-stone reference is modeled over six hours; it is a convention for defining the unit, not an established average of clinical episodes. The reference does not validate the assumed equivalence between different forms of suffering. USU is experimental and complements the other statistics shown in each report.

Read the reference definition and assumptions →

Why use kidney-stone pain as the reference?

A concrete reference can make the amount of suffering behind an estimate easier to picture. One USU is defined using a specified six-hour kidney-stone pain profile. The profile is a convention, not an average patient trajectory, and it does not imply that pain ends after six hours.

Choosing a reference defines the scale. Establishing how other experiences relate to it requires separate evidence and testing. Read about the reference →

How is an event’s USU estimate calculated?

We multiply a reported population or case count by an assumed average duration and intensity, then divide by the reference unit:

USU = count × days × 24 × intensity ÷ 47.25

We use shared course templates. All dengue entries, for example, use five days at average intensity 3 for other reported cases and seven days at average intensity 5 for reported fatal cases. When a report separates fatal illness from other cases, each case receives one course, and the group estimates are added. Each report shows the arithmetic and the basis for its choices.

How can these estimates help in practice?

They offer a starting point for comparing the scale of suffering across events. Readers can put news in perspective, journalists can explain an event’s human impact, and researchers can identify important experiences that are poorly measured or missing from public discussion.

For people deciding where to direct attention or support, these estimates are one input. Choosing an effective response also requires evidence about what help is available, what it costs and how much suffering it could prevent. An event’s USU estimate alone cannot answer those questions.

Our new Reducing suffering page begins connecting interventions, costs and modeled suffering prevented in a separate analysis.

What does USU averted or relieved per $100 mean?

It estimates the included suffering an intervention could prevent or relieve per $100 on a stated cost basis. Prevention counts avoided illness; relief counts a reduction in experienced intensity over time. Deaths prevented remain a separate outcome and may be unestimated.

The AMF estimate extends a documented grant model to future malaria programs. The fistula-repair estimate combines a broad cost allowance with assumptions about additional treatment and first-year relief. Published facts and WSI judgments are separated in both reports.

The Friendship Bench analysis adds an exploratory mental-health example. It discounts an older trial result and makes the assumed link from a screening outcome to experienced relief explicit. A no-added-effect scenario is included. Depression-score changes are not converted into deaths prevented.

They use different benefit windows and cost models, and adverse effects are not fully estimated. The headlines alone cannot establish a best charity. Scenarios are not confidence intervals.

Funding status is checked separately from impact. AMF reports a funding need. Fistula Foundation and Friendship Bench have donation routes, but their current remaining gaps and the next allocations have not been verified. The funded malaria examples use a different cost basis.

Can I compare two events using these numbers?

Yes, as estimates of the experiences included in each report under a common model. A larger number means more modeled suffering within that scope. Read the reporting period, population and included experience first: an acute disease course and a month of displacement cover different things.

The assumptions and surveillance coverage can change the comparison substantially. Even when two reports use the same disease template, they may count different kinds of cases. The table is a starting point for comparison, not a settled ranking of total harm.

Does the number cover all suffering caused by an event?

No. Each entry names what it includes. Disease entries cover ordinary acute illness and selected complete fatal courses; the flood entries cover an assumed initial period of displacement distress. Sudan covers a representative early course after malnutrition treatment admission, excluding suffering before admission and untreated children. Nepal and Mozambique cover the populations reported in displacement sites or accommodation centres, not all displaced people. Later illness, caregiver distress, bereavement and other consequences may be outside that estimate.

Unestimated does not mean zero. The figures are neither complete totals nor guaranteed lower bounds. Do not add event list rows: people and reporting periods can overlap.

Why are deaths shown separately?

USU concerns experienced suffering during lived time. Death itself and lost life years are not assigned USU. A death count describes a different, essential aspect of harm. Both appear together so that a reader does not mistake either for the whole picture.

Suffering before death can be included. In the dengue, Ebola and chikungunya reports, the reported deaths identify cases assigned a complete fatal illness course in place of the ordinary allowance. There is no extra charge for dying and no suffering after death. A report also explains whether its death count covers the modeled population or a broader event.

How do you include suffering before death without counting it twice?

For an illness already in the estimate, we replace the ordinary course for reported fatal cases with one complete fatal illness course. The Bangladesh dengue report, for example, separates 327 reported fatal cases from 69,156 other cases. The same rule applies to all dengue entries, Ebola and the 52 CHIKV-attributable deaths in the Paraguay chikungunya report. “Other” includes unresolved outcomes and does not mean all are known survivors.

For a separate experience such as drowning, we need an eligible count and a check for overlap. The Rio Grande do Sul report includes an illustrative calculation, but its statewide snapshot lacks an aligned breakdown by fatal mechanism. A later regional review does not supply that statewide breakdown. No actual drowning addition enters the headline. For chikungunya, the attributable deaths belong to a narrower probable/confirmed subset within the total. We do not extrapolate its death rate; other-cause and pending deaths do not receive the fatal-course replacement.

Read the inclusion rules →

Why is fatal suffering unestimated in some reports?

A death toll alone does not tell us which experience to model. Flood deaths can involve different mechanisms, and a whole-event mortality count can cover a different population from the displacement estimate. We need a source-aligned count and an explicit decision about overlap before assigning a simple course.

The four flood reports record their specific evidence gaps. Sudan's malnutrition report has no matched death count for its selected treatment admissions, so a separate fatal course is also unestimated. “Unestimated” means the experience is outside the current USU calculation, not that it has zero suffering. Seven disease entries identify fatal cases within their modeled case populations and replace those cases’ ordinary allowance with one complete fatal course. The Mauritius chikungunya snapshot reports no associated deaths in its source summary, so no separate fatal course is assigned; the report explains that source limitation.

The note beneath each event’s USU number links directly to its inclusion decision. Read the coverage review →

Is the suffering of relatives included?

Not in this version. Bereavement and caregiver distress are unestimated, not assumed to be zero. We are starting with direct experiences and keeping the calculation simple.

Does WSI measure animal suffering?

Not currently. WSI’s published estimates focus on human suffering. The USU framework may eventually be adapted to estimate animal suffering, but this would need separate evidence and testing. Assumptions about human pain and distress cannot simply be applied to other species.

This is a possible future experimental use, not a feature planned for the next few months. No release date has been set.

How reliable are the intensity and duration assumptions?

They are provisional and can be substantially wrong. Sources provide reported counts, clinical duration ranges and descriptions of distress. The exact average intensity is our judgment, not a measured conversion supplied by WHO, CDC or another source.

We use simple representative courses to keep the calculation inspectable. Historical clinical studies inform the fatal durations, but their patients, treatment settings and outcomes differ from those in the listed events. Intensity averages across the whole elapsed day, including relief and sleep. Each report also shows how alternative assumptions change the estimate. Those examples are not confidence intervals.

What does the new simulation study tell us?

The v3 preprint, published on 29 October 2026, tests a proposed duration-matching procedure using simulated respondents. It shows that keeping only completed matches can bias the result, and examines when a model retaining response bounds helps.

It does not show that real participants make stable suffering comparisons, and it does not calibrate the intensity assumptions in WSI reports. Those remain provisional. The paper and its supplementary materials are publicly available and have not been peer reviewed.

Why these events?

This is a small proof of concept, selected for identifiable public sources and conditions we can describe with a shared template. It is not a representative sample of global suffering or a list of the world’s worst events.

The list currently contains thirteen reports. The newest addition is Mauritius chikungunya in 2026, using the existing acute illness course. We are actively expanding the list; each snapshot retains its stated reporting date and is not a live surveillance total.

Does the Sudan estimate cover all malnutrition suffering?

No. It assigns one representative six-week early treatment and recovery course to each reported admission, at average intensity 2. Suffering before admission, untreated children and later effects are outside this estimate. Treatment duration is not itself a measure of suffering; improvement, relief and sleep are represented within the average intensity.

UNICEF's narrative gives 174,737 admissions, while its results table gives 238,099. We select the narrative figure provisionally, producing about 7.5 million USU. Using the table count gives about 10.2 million USU. The report shows the unresolved discrepancy; it does not average or add these counts. Unique-child deduplication is not established.

More admissions can reflect better access to treatment or reporting. This estimate is not a measure of suffering prevented by treatment. Read the Sudan report →

Where did the background guides go?

Useful data explanations now link directly from the relevant crisis reports. The research archive preserves the full set of supporting guides and earlier work. These materials retain their own dates and populations and should not be treated as current crisis estimates.

Why do earlier USU research pilots show different figures?

The earlier pilots tested different approaches and time bases, including daily and population-adjusted estimates. Their original values remain available as research background. The current event list uses one cumulative formula and should not be combined directly with those pilot outputs.

More detailed questions about the research framework →

Does WSI collect donations?

No. This website publishes research and estimates. The dollar amounts are calculation inputs used to explore the possible cost of relief. Any links to charities lead to those organizations' own websites.

Donation estimates model money received by an organization; program-cost estimates model resources used to deliver an intervention. Neither is a guaranteed result. Explore the analyses →

Can I inspect the inputs or suggest a correction?

Yes. Each report links to its sources, and the crisis report list offers CSV and JSON downloads with the counts, assumptions and mortality notes. A shared-template revision applies to every linked event.

To suggest an improvement or flag an error, email WSI. Include a link to the report and the input or wording in question. A supporting source is helpful.

Search WSI